Tomato parable
I wrote some code to embed my tweets on my website. There’s a statement that would have made no sense in 1990. Actually, it barely makes sense now. But I did it. I’m proud of my site. I built it myself. Occasionally I get an email saying, “What software do you use to run your site and how do I get it?” I think the answer is: receive a Commodore 64 for your tenth birthday and no good games.
But that’s not why I’m writing. I’m writing because I decided to grow my own vegetables. A few people I knew were growing their own vegetables, and they kept yakking about how wonderful it was, not depending on manufactured supermarket vegetables, which are evil for some reason, so I thought what the hell.
For a while I was intimidated by the idea of growing vegetables. When I reach for a vegetable, I usually just want to eat it. I don’t want to be intimately involved with its creation. I worried I would end up spending more time tending to the health of fragile, overly complicated peas than eating them.
Then I saw an ad for genetically modified seeds. These promised to take the hassle out of growing vegetables, which seemed pretty intriguing. The tomatoes would be big and red and I wouldn’t have to do anything. So I got those.
This upset my hippy friends. Especially when I started having problems. My frankenfruit was supposed to be simple but after a few weeks the whole garden stopped growing. My cabbages were flaccid. My carrots were anemic. My spinach wouldn’t self-seed. It wasn’t supposed to self-seed. The genetics company had engineered it not to, so I’d have to buy new seeds each season. But I thought there should be a way around that.
I asked my hippy friends for help. Well! You’d think I asked for a kidney. They kept bringing up the fact that I was using GM seeds. Eventually they all got together and said, “Max… we can’t help you any more. We want to. But you brought these problems on yourself. And the thing is, when you ask for help, you’re actually asking us to use our skills and knowledge to prop up a corporatized product that’s not just practically inferior to the free alternative you ignored, but actually bad for the world. We just can’t do that.”
And that was how I taught them to stop asking me for help with Windows.
Comments
This is where site members post comments. If you're not a member, you can join here. There are all kinds of benefits, including moral superiority!
shabooty (#637)
Location: D.C./V.A/M.D.
Quote: "I will shake your foundation. I will shake the f**cking rafters. Nobody'll be the same -Danny Bonaduce ....& go visit my blog @: http://www.shabooty.com"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Max
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Quote: "I'm my number one fan!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Karan (#1376)
Location: Sydney, Australia
Quote: "Quid Quid Latine Dictum Sit, Altum Viditur - Anything said in Latin sounds important"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Narain (#824)
Location: Los Angeles, right between civilization and a desert
Quote: "NI!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Jenifer (#1868)
Location: Suwon, South Korea
Quote: ""I'll try everything once. If I like it, I'll try it again.""
Posted: 5010 days ago
Mapuche (#1184)
Location: Darwin, Australia
Quote: "Inconceivable!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Stygian Emperor (#2947)
Location: the Stygian Empire
Quote: "Flesh is a design flaw."
Posted: 5010 days ago
It's edu-tainment.
Alan W (#1427)
Location: Spokane, Washington
Quote: "Corgis are like potato chips"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Steve (#2499)
Location: Michigan
Quote: "Max Barry's writing rocks. And he didn't even pay me to write that."
Posted: 5010 days ago
Alan W (#1427)
Location: Spokane, Washington
Quote: "Corgis are like potato chips"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Greg Karber (#1568)
Location: gregkarber.com
Posted: 5010 days ago
Jane (#321)
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Quote: "Which is worse: Ignorance or apathy? Who knows? Who cares?"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Simon (#3192)
Location: Melbourne
Quote: "I'd rather be arrogant than wrong"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Barrie (#5111)
Location: Blackheath Australia
Quote: "So be it, mergatron!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Get a Mac Max and give yourself a break.
Windows ebil!
gstein42 (#585)
Location: 127.0.0.1
Quote: "That's not change! That's more of the same!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
and Barrie, *nix is still superior to apple computers, even if only in that the OS is free, open-sourced, and is compatible with a more hardware options.
Stygian Emperor (#2947)
Location: the Stygian Empire
Quote: "Flesh is a design flaw."
Posted: 5010 days ago
RaYdeX (#5311)
Location: Canberra
Quote: "I'm unique. Just like everybody else."
Posted: 5010 days ago
Mac would be the Windows in your analogy. GM Linux. Designed to keep you going back to the manufacturer as often as possible, to get the slightly newer seed, that's actually just a slightly smaller old seed, that doesn't do anything extra. Bad for the world. The natural goodness removed, and injected with some corporate greed.
Windows has always been this way, there never was an innocent and free version.
John Thomson (#5303)
Location: Gretna, UK
Quote: ""And that was how I taught them to stop asking me for help with Windows.""
Posted: 5010 days ago
Max, Great post! Can't wait to get my hands on another one of your books.
Thomas (#1221)
Location: Germany
Quote: "One more, and I'm going to consider you my penpal."
Posted: 5010 days ago
Mlaz (#5134)
Location: Nether-lands
Posted: 5010 days ago
nick (#3850)
Location: Melbourne
Quote: "Pick me, pick me, I'm ever so smart!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
stanley becker (#5283)
Location: black hole
Quote: "DON"T JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER!!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
TotesEichhorn (#4757)
Location: Vienna - Austria
Quote: "marketing IS modern propaganda"
Posted: 5010 days ago
GM veggies are not my favorite. I like the local plants and their taste, as seldom as i devour them.
Anyway nice topic & greets from "up over"
Kyle (#3321)
Location: Burnie, Tasmania
Posted: 5010 days ago
Max we cant help you any more. We want to. But you brought these problems on yourself. And the thing is, when you ask for help, youre actually asking us to use our skills and knowledge to prop up a corporatized product thats not just practically inferior to the free alternative you ignored, but actually bad for the world. We just cant do that.
I rolled my eyes at that, sans the irony. There are people walking around with their eyes shut in every political scene.
Todd (#3429)
Location: New York
Quote: "It's fun to have fun but you have to know how."
Posted: 5010 days ago
Guy Wright (#2861)
Location: Toronto, Canada, eh
Quote: "push the button max! (Jack Lemmon as Prof. Fate)"
Posted: 5010 days ago
How are you finding parenthood the second time around? "Two are as easy as one". Anyone told you that? It's not true. Most of what you learn with the first one you can toss out the window when it comes to the second one. But I hope you are getting the most out of it - the time goes faster than you can imagine and when it's good it's very good.
Mike Kowols (#3435)
Location: Des Plaines, IL
Posted: 5010 days ago
James (#5313)
Location: Newport Beach
Posted: 5010 days ago
Don't get me wrong, I'm not a Windows lover - I own two Macbooks, an iPad and two Windows 7 systems; it's just funny how pure Apple fans think their world is so much nicer.
It's merely been ignored by those who can make it hell.
Kelly (#5314)
Posted: 5010 days ago
Nate Murray (#1176)
Location: San Diego
Quote: "You can run, but you can't glide!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Aquinas (#4890)
Location: New Zealand
Posted: 5010 days ago
Max
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Quote: "I'm my number one fan!"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Of course, Microsoft is getting better and Apple is getting worse, so maybe in time I will feel the same deep, abiding hate for Apple as I do for MS. But Apple users have never pestered me for help removing spyware.
Simon (#3192)
Location: Melbourne
Quote: "I'd rather be arrogant than wrong"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Agent_Johnny (#5316)
Location: Dirt
Quote: "Nunya"
Posted: 5010 days ago
Disclosure: This has nothing to do with Linux
Toby O (#2900)
Location: Sydney
Quote: "vote with your wallet"
Posted: 5009 days ago
if Ripe then Eat
John Thomson (#5303)
Location: Gretna, UK
Quote: ""And that was how I taught them to stop asking me for help with Windows.""
Posted: 5009 days ago
Max: Couldn't agree more. And (as you know) I've put this post on my site, it's that good (the post, not my site lol). www.johnthomson.me.uk/
stanley becker (#5283)
Location: black hole
Quote: "DON"T JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER!!"
Posted: 5009 days ago
John Thomson (#5303)
Location: Gretna, UK
Quote: ""And that was how I taught them to stop asking me for help with Windows.""
Posted: 5009 days ago
Adam Willard (#4231)
Location: USA
Quote: "What unseen pen etched eternal things in the hearts of humankind... but never let them in our minds?"
Posted: 5007 days ago
David (#1456)
Location: Sydney, Australia
Quote: "Why are the pretty ones always insane?"
Posted: 5006 days ago
1. Despite stories (ahem) and many statements to the contrary by supporters of "natural" foods no commercially available GM seeds are actually sterile. The technology to sterilise them (the infamous 'terminator' gene) was developed by Monsanto (with the US DoA btw) but it has *never been used*. Not by Monsanto and not by anyone else (Monsanto have patents, and lawyers...). Why? Because of the outcry that arose when they started talking about it years ago. They dropped the idea like a radioactive potato and it shows no signs of being revived.
2. This lack of a terminator gene upset many environmentalists and anti-GM people - they see it as too risky too have fertile GM seeds in the environment able to mix it up with wild species. They *liked* the idea of sterile seeds, it was the farmers who hated it and led to Monsanto dropping the idea (they didn't want to upset their customers, weird eh?)
3. Many species of non-GM hybrid seeds (created by cross-pollination) that have been widely used in agriculture for many years (early 20th century) are sterile and always have been. We've been growing and eating these since our grandparents were in nappies.
4. As a result of the panicky GM furore over the last decade or so many people now assume that if seeds are sterile they must be GM, when in fact just the opposite is true...
John Thomson (#5303)
Location: Gretna, UK
Quote: ""And that was how I taught them to stop asking me for help with Windows.""
Posted: 5006 days ago
As for food, if it is done correctly, then it's fine. My main concern, though, is that due to the corrupt nature of the entire capitalist system, therefore the whole world, things like this are never going to work to the advantage of everyone, and it will turn out to be the most needy who don't get it.
Dawne Webber (#5346)
Location: Michigan, USA
Posted: 4988 days ago
The "aha" moment came a few days later out of the blue. I get it.
Thanks for building my intellectual self-esteem. There is hope for me.
Comments are now closed for this post.